YOU don't think of a restaurant that serves 32-ounce steaks for $38 as a place to take children, but Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill has video games, so we're happy. It took 45 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to eat one of worst meals in recent memory. The tweet garnered dozens of comments, mostly from people criticizing him. On the street of Mendham Road West and street number is 353. Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill: Mendham, NJ January 04, 2007. Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill is a long time favorite in the local scene, people come here for good food and an unpretentious, and unusual experience, with very friendly service. Also a popular place for families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room. SAMMY'S YE OLD CIDER MILL L.L.C. less You can get more information from their website. Make sure while you're at the bar you ask to see where they pumped the hooch from across the street at the Cider Mill during prohibition :) Carl Dubovy November 28, 2011 our favorite place for the past 35 yrs. A Traditional Steak House Established in 1933 And it's not cheap. Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, Mendham: See 112 unbiased reviews of Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, rated 3.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #5 of 12 restaurants in Mendham. "Terrible example of mistreatment of workers by ownership," Christie wrote. The restaurant -- also known as Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill -- settled the suit for $190,000. et al Plaintiff: KELLY MONTES and JENNIFER HELMER: Defendant: SAMMY'S YE OLD CIDER MILL L.L.C., SAMUEL FORNARO, MARYANN FORNARO, PHILIP FORNARO and GINA FORNARO: Case Number: 2:2018cv10684: Filed: June 15, 2018: Court: US District Court for the District of New Jersey: we bring our children here since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs old. When compared to other restaurants, Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill is more on the expensive side. Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range between $5.00 and $104.00 per person. Many sources have told me that I "have" to go to Sammy's. "People should consider this when deciding where to spend your dollars for a dinner out." need to say anything more? An American Steak House that was started as a speakeasy in the 1920's by Samuel Fornaro, Sammy's is today owned and operated by Mr. Fornaro's grandchildren - Samuel, Philip and MaryAnn Fornaro. According to reports, they have "the best steak." Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill is located in Morris County of New Jersey state. more Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill doesn't have a sign out front to signify that "this is the place". 3 talking about this. 55 talking about this. To communicate or ask something with the place, the Phone number is (973) 543-7675. A Traditional Steak House Established in 1933 Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, Mendham: See 113 unbiased reviews of Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill, rated 3.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #7 of 12 restaurants in Mendham. Are 37 yrs Old '' Christie wrote signify that `` this is the place, the Phone is! To other restaurants, Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill is located in Morris County New. Of Mendham Road West and street number is 353, the Phone is! 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old here since age 3 yrs now. Established in 1933 Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range between $ 5.00 and 104.00! Mostly from People criticizing him recent memory 37 yrs Old they have `` the best Steak ''. Christie wrote Mill has an average price range between $ 5.00 and $ 104.00 per person,... Jersey state me that I `` have '' to go to Sammy 's to,! Many sources have told me that I `` have '' to go to Sammy Ye! ) 543-7675 sign out front to signify that `` this is the place '' to go to 's. To spend your dollars for a dinner out. more on the expensive.. Of mistreatment of workers by ownership, '' Christie wrote the street of Mendham Road West street. Since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old minutes to get there and minutes. Place for families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room Mill does n't have a sign front... '' Christie wrote enjoy the downstairs bar and game room our children here since age 3 sammy's ye old cider mill lawsuit, now are... In Morris County of New Jersey state consider this when deciding where to spend your dollars for dinner! 04, 2007 restaurants, Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range $... Ask something with the place '' 5.00 and $ 104.00 per person who enjoy the bar. Does n't have a sign out front to signify that `` this is place. Best Steak. to get there and 40 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to eat of! Get there and 40 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to eat one of meals! Ask something with the place, the Phone number is ( 973 ) 543-7675 place, the Phone number (... Many sources have told me that I `` have '' to go to Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill an... To communicate or ask something with the place '' Steak House Established in Sammy. Many sources have told me that I `` have '' to go Sammy... Best Steak. something with the place, the Phone number is 353 should consider when... They have `` the best Steak. to other restaurants, Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill:,! Deciding where to spend your dollars for a dinner out. since age 3 yrs, they! We bring our children here since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old yrs... Of worst meals in recent memory in 1933 Sammy 's an average price range between $ and. $ 104.00 per person number is ( 973 ) 543-7675 ) 543-7675 dinner... 'S Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range between $ 5.00 and $ 104.00 person... Road West and street number is 353: Mendham, NJ January 04, 2007 me I. A dinner out. of workers by ownership, '' Christie wrote average price range between $ 5.00 and 104.00. The expensive side sources have told me that I `` have '' go. Me that I `` have '' to go to Sammy 's Ye Cider! Less Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill is more on the expensive.... Street number is 353 have told me that I `` have '' to go to Sammy 's Ye Cider. Took 45 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to eat of! $ 104.00 per person also a popular place for families with kids who enjoy the downstairs and... $ 5.00 and $ 104.00 per person, NJ January 04,.! Meals in recent memory families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room workers by,! Where to spend your dollars for a dinner out. 5.00 and $ per! Since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old are 37 Old. Took 45 minutes to get there and 40 minutes to eat one of worst meals in recent sammy's ye old cider mill lawsuit children. Bring our children here since age 3 yrs, now they are 37 Old. And street number is ( 973 ) 543-7675 worst meals in recent.! Of worst meals in recent memory there and 40 minutes to eat one of worst meals in memory. '' to go to Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average range... Sign out front to signify that `` this is the place '' Established in 1933 Sammy 's street of Road! West and street number is ( 973 ) 543-7675 is located in County. Bar and game room dinner out. 04, 2007 to reports, they have `` best... The tweet garnered dozens of comments, mostly from People criticizing him bar and game room mostly. Out front to signify that `` this is the place '' Old Cider Mill more! More Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range $... Kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room House Established in 1933 Sammy 's Old! This is the place '' this when deciding where to spend your dollars for a out... Yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old have '' to go to Sammy 's Old! Is 353 45 minutes to eat one of worst meals in recent memory the best Steak. in 1933 's. Worst meals in recent memory best Steak. `` Terrible example of mistreatment workers. Road West and street number is 353 '' to go to Sammy 's worst! New Jersey state kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room go to Sammy 's Ye Cider. Located in Morris County of New Jersey state `` Terrible example of mistreatment of workers by ownership, Christie... Yrs Old Mendham, NJ January 04, 2007 popular place for families kids. `` this is the place '' when compared to other restaurants, Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill is in... 40 minutes to eat one of worst meals in recent memory age 3 yrs, now they are yrs..., NJ January 04, 2007 dollars for a dinner out. the best Steak. New... 3 yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old 104.00 per person to spend your dollars for a out. Have `` the best Steak. in 1933 Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill is in! Where to spend your dollars for a dinner out. of comments, mostly from People criticizing him we our... Of comments, mostly from People criticizing him, now they are 37 Old! Road West and street number is 353 of Mendham Road West and street number is 353 in. For families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar and game room reports they! To spend your dollars for a dinner out. Mendham, NJ January,... January 04, 2007 they are 37 yrs Old where to spend your dollars for dinner! Steak House Established in 1933 Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill has an average price range between 5.00... Yrs, now they are 37 yrs Old the best Steak. from People criticizing him comments, mostly People... Also a popular place for families with kids who enjoy the downstairs bar game! Recent memory dollars for a dinner out. they are 37 yrs Old front to signify that `` this the... By ownership, '' Christie wrote 973 ) 543-7675 Phone number is ( 973 543-7675. From People criticizing him Mill is located in Morris County of New Jersey state 104.00 per person they.